Exclusive collision filter broken?

This feature seems to be utterly broken.

In a very simple test with:

2 sprites

2 3D objects

sprites on Created

Set collision filter "wall" as exclusive

3D objects have collision filter "wall" as exclusive

on the editor.

NONE of them exclusive collision with either one.

Here is the CAPx

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qPxfJPSzfAEM4Zn7l0NRo1cFHolTBlFb/view?usp=sharing

The feature should be working correctly - the problem with your project is you've set up the collision filter incorrectly. You've set up two kinds of objects to use exclusive collision filter with tags "wall", meaning they will collide with everything except things tagged "wall". But nothing has any tags at all - all the 'Tags' fields of all the objects are empty. So the collision filter will do nothing. It looks like you confused giving objects tags via the 'Tags' field with specifying the tags to filter by in the collision filter.

I do have tags set:

3D object have the tag "wall" preset in the editor.

sprite gets the tag set on create.

But lets move the 3D objects out the equation.

then i have the following sprites with physics.

Test : Get tag "wall" on created as exclusive

Player : Have no tag.

Test: Should not collide with each other BUT with player.

/ They still collide with each other, AND the player

Okay, having to set duplicated tags for this system is very confusing in my opinion. Should be handled solely with the tag in the Physics Setting in my opinion.

The feature should be working correctly - the problem with your project is you've set up the collision filter incorrectly. You've set up two kinds of objects to use exclusive collision filter with tags "wall", meaning they will collide with everything except things tagged "wall". But nothing has any tags at all - all the 'Tags' fields of all the objects are empty. So the collision filter will do nothing. It looks like you confused giving objects tags via the 'Tags' field with specifying the tags to filter by in the collision filter.

Thanks Ashley, you might want to clearify this in your document system. It does not state that the tag system ONLY works with whatever is set in "Commen".