The future of Construct

Not favoritedFavorited Favorited 1 favourites
From the Asset Store
Casino? money? who knows? but the target is the same!
  • > If you allow it, I can have an open-source, MCP-supporting version of Construct built within days.

    Do it. Go ask AI to create a slop engine to help you create more slop. I doubt many people will use it. The backlash to AI is just beginning. Authenticity has always been a currency, but when human made things become scarce, it becomes even more valuable.

    If I had c3 company authorization, I guarantee I could release a polished open-source version in less than a week. It’s just meaningless because using AI to generate custom engines is faster and more efficient (I’ve bought two M5 Ultra 256). Like our signature web3-based game running engines that (see: x.com/willfauchervfx/status/2120142352060653886 are now practically (only making money from successful projects and big companies) have reached a state of living in space, thing happen just paired AI to MCP, c3 is now like a retro toy. When the worldschanging and now just finally think about webmcp…now?

    (A year or two ago, I eagerly pleaded with admins to lift unreasonable restrictions, like the username limit for MP plugins allowing PUBKEY in players name. Now I feel how naive and time-wasting that was, even getting warned by them for “rude language.”)

    there is no hope if c3 reject that community base, i havent login the editor for a long while. thats part of my life before, the gap too big from the current stage of makinf game

  • > That said, I'm honestly amazed that Construct 3 still doesn't have official MCP support.

    As I mentioned previously, the main reason is WebMCP isn't enabled by default in Chrome yet, so even if we added support, it wouldn't work out-of-the-box yet. WebMCP looks like it will be shipping soon though, probably early next year, at which point we'll look into integrating it.

    man, i dont get it, i'm working on a personal AI assistant that can even control your computer and phone (I'm not advertising; I haven't publicly released it yet, just an incomplete technical example. I can remove the link if you want; I'm just proving I'm not just making this up). Honestly, if i am part of C3 team, I could handle all your accumulated needs within a month, and remove those unreasonable restrictions. then I'd persuade you every day to create a community version similar to the C2 era, charging only to large clients. Otherwise, I don't know what the point is, even though you know this will eventually become history. Am I wrong?

  • You will NEVER be able to tell whether a game developer used AI to make their game or not. The changes AI has brought to game development are already irreversible. You can keep living in your ivory tower and pretending nothing is happening. Or, if all else fails, you can downvote this post. Maybe it'll give you a little sense of relief for a while.

    Never say never. AI knows you used it and it's a lot smarter than you. That information can be used in many different ways. You are not using AI in the dark. And no one is pretending nothing is happening. It's not me downvoting your posts. I don't down vote anyone. You can check my profile.

    If I had c3 company authorization, I guarantee I could release a polished open-source version in less than a week. It’s just meaningless because using AI to generate custom engines is faster and more efficient (I’ve bought two M5 Ultra 256). Like our signature web3-based game running engines that (see: x.com/willfauchervfx/status/2120142352060653886 are now practically (only making money from successful projects and big companies) have reached a state of living in space, thing happen just paired AI to MCP, c3 is now like a retro toy. When the worldschanging and now just finally think about webmcp…now?

    Why do you pretend to be worried about authorization? AI is trained on unauthorized sources. By using it, you already crossed that moral line. And there's already a C3 clone and the last time I checked, it was free. What would even be the point? If you use AI, you don't need C3. You can just tell AI what game to make using ANY game engine you want. The only value C3 has is people wanting to make game themselves. So leave it alone. Go use AI on your own and don't try to force it on all of us.

    I want C3, I don't need C3. The day C3 implements AI features is the day I don't want it anymore.

  • Slightly off topic, but here's an interesting discussion about AI and many aspects of it. They get into the benefits and dangers of AI.

    Subscribe to Construct videos now
  • > You will NEVER be able to tell whether a game developer used AI to make their game or not. The changes AI has brought to game development are already irreversible. You can keep living in your ivory tower and pretending nothing is happening. Or, if all else fails, you can downvote this post. Maybe it'll give you a little sense of relief for a while.

    Never say never. AI knows you used it and it's a lot smarter than you. That information can be used in many different ways. You are not using AI in the dark. And no one is pretending nothing is happening. It's not me downvoting your posts. I don't down vote anyone. You can check my profile.

    >

    > If I had c3 company authorization, I guarantee I could release a polished open-source version in less than a week. It’s just meaningless because using AI to generate custom engines is faster and more efficient (I’ve bought two M5 Ultra 256). Like our signature web3-based game running engines that (see: x.com/willfauchervfx/status/2120142352060653886 are now practically (only making money from successful projects and big companies) have reached a state of living in space, thing happen just paired AI to MCP, c3 is now like a retro toy. When the worldschanging and now just finally think about webmcp…now?

    Why do you pretend to be worried about authorization? AI is trained on unauthorized sources. By using it, you already crossed that moral line. And there's already a C3 clone and the last time I checked, it was free. What would even be the point? If you use AI, you don't need C3. You can just tell AI what game to make using ANY game engine you want. The only value C3 has is people wanting to make game themselves. So leave it alone. Go use AI on your own and don't try to force it on all of us.

    I want C3, I don't need C3. The day C3 implements AI features is the day I don't want it anymore.

    I think you have reading difficulties. I need the community version and MCP; that's the foundation. not about AI can directly generate custom engines, while manual lines are valuable in C3, but that doesn't mean it's necessary to restrict connectivity. The key is that creation involves my game, my production process, and I should have the right to choose. I think you're disrespecting the value of text. You're one of those people who should use AI to avoid missing content. I like freedom. Do you even understand what a community was like in the C2 era? Back then, official plugins could be freely branched, achieving many amazing functions, and third-party communities were extremely active. What does that have to do with AI? You clearly need AI to assist you in reading.。

    ps: c2→C3 they even cut off the PM function of this forum. I couldn't even find the communication methods of many friends.

  • I think you have reading difficulties. I need the community version and MCP; that's the foundation. not about AI can directly generate custom engines, while manual lines are valuable in C3, but that doesn't mean it's necessary to restrict connectivity. The key is that creation involves my game, my production process, and I should have the right to choose. I think you're disrespecting the value of text. You're one of those people who should use AI to avoid missing content. I like freedom. Do you even understand what a community was like in the C2 era? Back then, official plugins could be freely branched, achieving many amazing functions, and third-party communities were extremely active. What does that have to do with AI? You clearly need AI to assist you in reading.。

    ps: c2→C3 they even cut off the PM function of this forum. I couldn't even find the communication methods of many friends.

    After reading that response, I understand why you need AI so much.

  • I think there is a fundamental divide among developers when it comes to understanding what AI is actually used for and what purposes it serves.

    The easiest way to explain this is with an example:

    Let's say you're developing an RTS game and you ask AI to write a pathfinding algorithm for your units. This algorithm is arguably one of the most technically challenging and time-consuming parts of developing an RTS game. So, would it be fair to call the game AI slop just because you used AI to create the algorithm? Would any player have a legitimate reason to criticize the developer for using AI for this particular task? The answer is obvious.

    Lately, we're seeing more and more games that are created entirely by AI with just one or two prompts. I don't think I need to explain that the easier game development tools become, the lower the barrier to entry into game development. And the lower that barrier, the lower the overall quality of the average game tends to be.

    Construct 3 was once one of the tools designed to lower that barrier, allowing people with no programming experience to create games. Does that mean Construct 3 is evil? I don't think so. And for the same reason, I don't consider AI development tools to be evil either.

    P.S. If you visit Construct Arcade, you'll find that 99% of the games there are of significantly lower quality than the average AI-generated game. I believe we shouldn't judge a tool solely by how the majority of its users choose to use it.

  • Try Construct 3

    Develop games in your browser. Powerful, performant & highly capable.

    Try Now Construct 3 users don't see these ads
  • Suppose you AI generate an entire game, and you have a folder with loads of code and data files you haven't looked at. Then you play the game, and you think "this level is OK, but those objects could do with being moved around a bit." I think in this case there is still value to having an editor - in Construct's case, you can just drag and drop them in the editor, and eyeball it as you move things around, shuffling objects around until you are happy it all looks good. Or do you try to explain to the AI what you want in a chat interface, and keep saying "a bit further over... no, the other way... actually go in that other direction a bit..."? It may seem old-fashioned now but I think having an editor still has its uses even if you want to AI-generate your stuff. As I mentioned earlier, there are still people who prefer to avoid AI, but I think many people will fall in a middle-ground, using AI for tedious or boring things, and using their own creativity the rest of the time.

    Back then, official plugins could be freely branched, achieving many amazing functions

    I just want to point out (again) that this was an absolute compatibility disaster and ended up ruining lots of customer projects, which is why we took steps to prevent it. In several cases the same or a better result could be achieved without having to modify official addons, so doing it that way was strictly the worst possible approach; in those cases closing off the option actually guides developers to better solutions. I can see how for some people it's a fun thing to tinker with, but it is not a serious way to develop commercial software. Where we have to choose between "developers can have fun tinkering with the core engine" vs. "Construct is a good product for customers and protects the integrity of their work", I think the only responsible thing to do is to choose the latter.

    ps: c2→C3 they even cut off the PM function of this forum.

    That was because it was being abused: there was harassment going on, and even people running marketing campaigns, including trying to persuade people to stop using Construct, conducted entirely through PMs. The only way to mitigate that is to moderate people's "private" messages, which means routinely looking at them. With modern rules around data protection private messaging systems are a nightmare and likely to result in onerous legal liabilities, so despite the utility of them, I'm afraid I'm glad we did away with it.

  • There is a long history with the addon problem, if you are using the AI and want a hex based game, for example, you will get suggestions to use Phaser with the rexrainbow library. The AI tries to find whatever fits your requirement, human or not.

    In another example I tried to solve my sprites being slightly out of focus (not using phaser). This is a problem that Construct 3 solves extremely well. There is a lot to this problem that the AI needs explained to it -- do I put the resized sprite down before or after the screen zoom and rotation or the fog effect. Do I zoom all your sprites first and use those or do I zoom distant ones in layers at different times. It takes days figuring out what makes your sprites blurry and what doesn't using the standard AI browser based game approaches--and then when you ask it to optimize for rendering speed it all goes out the window and you have to start over.

    There is no doubt that Construct 3 does this (and other) things very well, and I would love to use it instead of prompting an AI over and over again explaining just what is blurry when and and what is not. In fact, the initial editor for sprite placement in construct 3 is also superb.

    However, there are boring things (like database stuff with user interfaces and saved game lists etc.) that the AI will do well that let you move miles ahead with your game that take a long long time with construct 3.

    In short, I want to use Construct 3 and AI.

    This post has been a bit unfocused, but I wanted to give credit to Construct 3 where it is due.

    yours

    winkr7

  • Ashley How do you see C3 in future?

    Will it remain an accessibility tool, helping people who don't think like programmers make games themselves, or just an AI accessory tool for games, trying to fix what AI can't get right... yet? What happens when AI companies replace typed prompts with verbal prompts? You can tell AI to just move this object a couple pixels to the left. It will be a lot faster than opening the game in an editor like C3, and manually doing it yourself. AI will only get smarter and faster at doing everything.

    Honestly, your company might be doomed either way, but it will almost certainly fail as an accessory tool for making games using AI. Adding a little AI is a slippery slope, because now you opened the door to people asking for more AI features. The thing about lazy people, they just want to be more lazy. How long before using C3 is just too much effort for them? They are already making threats to replace your editor with an AI generated editor. Are these really the people you want to accommodate?

    My advice is to get into publishing. Keep C3 as a tool for humans to make games for humans, and be a trusted source for humans to find games made by other humans. Become the Etsy for indie games. Or ride down that slippery AI slope until you run out of slope. Just let us know what direction you're taking.

  • Yes, I would prefer to see Scirra use AI first(claude code), improve efficiency and clear through that Feature requests that may seem minor but help improve the user's quality of life, such as:

    JSON: Add more ACE
    JSON: Better Path Expressions
    Array: RowIndexOf
    Array: CurIndex expression
    Typewriter support more ACE
    HTML Element Support More ACE
    BBCode: br
    Collision polygon circle
    Function Dictionary
Jump to:
Active Users
There are 0 visitors browsing this topic (0 users and 0 guests)