fongka2's Forum Posts

  • > You will NEVER be able to tell whether a game developer used AI to make their game or not. The changes AI has brought to game development are already irreversible. You can keep living in your ivory tower and pretending nothing is happening. Or, if all else fails, you can downvote this post. Maybe it'll give you a little sense of relief for a while.

    Never say never. AI knows you used it and it's a lot smarter than you. That information can be used in many different ways. You are not using AI in the dark. And no one is pretending nothing is happening. It's not me downvoting your posts. I don't down vote anyone. You can check my profile.

    >

    > If I had c3 company authorization, I guarantee I could release a polished open-source version in less than a week. It’s just meaningless because using AI to generate custom engines is faster and more efficient (I’ve bought two M5 Ultra 256). Like our signature web3-based game running engines that (see: x.com/willfauchervfx/status/2120142352060653886 are now practically (only making money from successful projects and big companies) have reached a state of living in space, thing happen just paired AI to MCP, c3 is now like a retro toy. When the worldschanging and now just finally think about webmcp…now?

    Why do you pretend to be worried about authorization? AI is trained on unauthorized sources. By using it, you already crossed that moral line. And there's already a C3 clone and the last time I checked, it was free. What would even be the point? If you use AI, you don't need C3. You can just tell AI what game to make using ANY game engine you want. The only value C3 has is people wanting to make game themselves. So leave it alone. Go use AI on your own and don't try to force it on all of us.

    I want C3, I don't need C3. The day C3 implements AI features is the day I don't want it anymore.

    I think you have reading difficulties. I need the community version and MCP; that's the foundation. not about AI can directly generate custom engines, while manual lines are valuable in C3, but that doesn't mean it's necessary to restrict connectivity. The key is that creation involves my game, my production process, and I should have the right to choose. I think you're disrespecting the value of text. You're one of those people who should use AI to avoid missing content. I like freedom. Do you even understand what a community was like in the C2 era? Back then, official plugins could be freely branched, achieving many amazing functions, and third-party communities were extremely active. What does that have to do with AI? You clearly need AI to assist you in reading.。

    ps: c2→C3 they even cut off the PM function of this forum. I couldn't even find the communication methods of many friends.

  • Try Construct 3

    Develop games in your browser. Powerful, performant & highly capable.

    Try Now Construct 3 users don't see these ads
  • > That said, I'm honestly amazed that Construct 3 still doesn't have official MCP support.

    As I mentioned previously, the main reason is WebMCP isn't enabled by default in Chrome yet, so even if we added support, it wouldn't work out-of-the-box yet. WebMCP looks like it will be shipping soon though, probably early next year, at which point we'll look into integrating it.

    man, i dont get it, i'm working on a personal AI assistant that can even control your computer and phone (I'm not advertising; I haven't publicly released it yet, just an incomplete technical example. I can remove the link if you want; I'm just proving I'm not just making this up). Honestly, if i am part of C3 team, I could handle all your accumulated needs within a month, and remove those unreasonable restrictions. then I'd persuade you every day to create a community version similar to the C2 era, charging only to large clients. Otherwise, I don't know what the point is, even though you know this will eventually become history. Am I wrong?

  • > If you allow it, I can have an open-source, MCP-supporting version of Construct built within days.

    Do it. Go ask AI to create a slop engine to help you create more slop. I doubt many people will use it. The backlash to AI is just beginning. Authenticity has always been a currency, but when human made things become scarce, it becomes even more valuable.

    If I had c3 company authorization, I guarantee I could release a polished open-source version in less than a week. It’s just meaningless because using AI to generate custom engines is faster and more efficient (I’ve bought two M5 Ultra 256). Like our signature web3-based game running engines that (see: x.com/willfauchervfx/status/2120142352060653886 are now practically (only making money from successful projects and big companies) have reached a state of living in space, thing happen just paired AI to MCP, c3 is now like a retro toy. When the worldschanging and now just finally think about webmcp…now?

    (A year or two ago, I eagerly pleaded with admins to lift unreasonable restrictions, like the username limit for MP plugins allowing PUBKEY in players name. Now I feel how naive and time-wasting that was, even getting warned by them for “rude language.”)

    there is no hope if c3 reject that community base, i havent login the editor for a long while. thats part of my life before, the gap too big from the current stage of makinf game

  • Don't fantasize about using Construct for multiplayer games — I already explored this two years ago and found everything hitting dead ends. The official side treats it as one of their closed loops (I even built and shared an enhanced plugin before), but they never adopted it because the entire environment simply doesn't support a viable ecosystem. You end up making only small games, not medium-sized ones you can actually develop and grow — and frankly, not even matching what AI could produce in ten minutes. As the official team recently stated, Construct's positioning (based on their direction) is really for those who enjoy the nostalgic, hands-on experience of crafting small hobby games bit by bit. If you want to do something grand, drop the fantasy. This isn't Construct 2 from ten years ago.

  • If you allow it, I can have an open-source, MCP-supporting version of Construct built within days. I don't know how much longer you'll let a small circle of fans keep fueling your ego — from drawing the line between Space Engineers and Construct, to now recycling the same sunset talk we've heard for decades. As a prophet, my advice is to get the Construct brand back on a community-driven development path as soon as possible. It's not too late yet, but if you keep dragging your feet, one day we'll all see a notice from Construct thanking its supporters and announcing it's shutting down — that's the last thing I want to see, and your refusal to open up is walking it straight there.

    Obviously we're aware of everything happening with AI, and it's something we've been thinking about. There are of course all sorts of existing ways AI can already be used with Construct as has been mentioned already - modifying project files directly, using automation tools like Playwright, or just driving the regular UI via AI, are all techniques that work or might be able to. I am interested in developing something with WebMCP when it becomes available in browsers. I think that hits the spot between integrating AI without affecting the user interface - the way we'd implement it would be that if you don't want to use it then it doesn't change anything about how you use Construct or how it looks. So in other words you can have a completely AI-free experience of Construct if you want. However WebMCP is still in development and not enabled by default in browsers right now, and I'd prefer to only start experimenting with it once it's easy for people to try out. I think this might start happening some time earlyish next year.

    While I can see the advantages of various AI enhancements, I still think it's important to preserve an AI-free experience in Construct. I've said before that Construct should primarily be about human expression, and I stand by that; even if AI takes over the world, I would still want Construct to be a nice tool for people who want to work the good old fashioned way and not try to push AI stuff at them all the time. I think there may still be a gap in the market long-term for this kind of thing, partly because lots of people remain hostile to AI and want to avoid it (I don't intend to get into a whole debate about that, it's just something I think is the case, especially looking at responses to AI discussions on our forums), but also because there is more to life than maximizing efficiency. I think an interesting analogy is that computers have been better at chess than humans for a long time now, and yet people still play chess. It can be an enjoyably hobby or pursuit for its own sake - and historically Construct has had a large hobbyist userbase. So even if most of the world is AI generating all their stuff, there could well be a market for people who just don't really care about that and still like to work on things themselves, and I'd be happy to continue to develop Construct for them.

    I could be wrong about this - I don't think anyone knows exactly how all the disruption from AI is going to play out. But so long as people want software like Construct, we'll be keeping it going!

  • If you want to keep using NW.js, you can - it's still there in the r449 LTS release. Our stats show the vast majority of users are on the latest Construct release and also the vast majority of desktop exports are now for Windows WebView2, macOS WKWebView, and Linux CEF instead of NW.js. So I'd say that basically the switch has already happened, which means it's a bit late to be asking to change anything back.

    Okay, I have said what I want to say. I hope the development direction is benign. BTW, which one does nwjs.appfolder correspond to in the new one? to get the location of the c3 running file .exe?

  • For context, this Reddit comment I posted a while back explains some more of the reasons from moving away from NW.js. I know these transitions can be disruptive, but in the long run it's necessary to improve things, and by now the new exporters should support pretty much everything NW.js used to, such as with the File System object for accessing files and folders on disk.

    I'm actually glad we moved away from NW.js, because shortly after the move, this bug broke support for Steam. As the relevant feature is undocumented and unsupported, nobody is obliged to fix it, so it may well be broken permanently now. I always knew it was a risk relying on things like that because of the chance of exactly this scenario, and that was part of the motivation to move away from NW.js. Luckily we avoided that particular nightmare. Presumably if we had stuck with NW.js, that bug would be causing serious problems, and everyone would be demanding a fix or talking about other better technologies we ought to be using instead. Also moving to new technologies has enabled further improvements, such as better support for dual-GPU devices in the latest releases.

    In these cases we have to choose between continuing to suffer the faults of the technologies we've already chosen, or switch to better technologies and do our best to smooth the transition between them. If we have to choose between short term gain with long term pain, or short term pain with long term gain, in the end it's always best to choose the latter.

    I suggest we stop stopping anything further. You can right-click and select the option to show deprecated items. The annual fee we each contribute is sufficient to support the service's capacity. We shouldn't force things to stop. We're not switching from PowerPC to x86 and then to ARM; we're using standard Web3. Why not offer advanced options for users to decide for themselves? Released games aren't suitable for sudden framework changes, especially since C3 lacks robust one-click conversion capabilities (complex designs require significant time to modify old projects, contradicting the 2026 trend of reducing tool usage time). Furthermore, I have usage issues; the app doesn't directly show its location in the output (where is nwjs.appfolder in C3's webview2?). Only you have the statistics to know how many people rely on older builds (<449 or older). As far as I know, some have already started relying on self-built environments. We should act quickly instead of clinging to our own decisions. You should notice that every change drives away some loyal users. Since this is the result every time... Why don't we retain this NWJS build, which is unappealing from your perspective, very slow but relatively common and complete? The bugs you raised aren't serious; you can simply display "deprecated" and let advanced users consider and decide freely. A closed-source development path must be paired with an indispensable core or provide users with sufficient choices. Otherwise, you can't please everyone. A single choice will ultimately fragment users. When they have no other options, they will always look for alternatives. In the end, C3 will only become an art piece in your own eyes, offending everyone.

    Mate might hear your explanations and benefits once or twice, but not three times. Initially, they might adjust their plans to follow your direction, then, like me, roughly modify some C3 core components. But ultimately? the workload of these modifications outweighs the change of development platform. And as you've seen, many users who discussed C3 on Reddit 5+ years ago are no longer in the C3 section, but few platforms you know. I love observing the last posts/cm users make before leaving(like history story). It's great if you have a unique perspective on your path of, just please don't forcibly stop things when there are not "no other options." I'd rather your major changes be to the "object picker," a problem that's been around for over a decade, than this...

  • Yea so the point is There is nothing in “safety” when you can write any like cmd file and run them to do whatever you want, the new one export and njs they both do the same job share the same risk but njs always much more easy and fast to get the job done, also it’s good for extending yourself with github fun repo, isn’t good enough?

    We care IAP, real multiplayer, Image(web3), steam, buildin UI, object picker(real - simple picker!)…and lot of THEM we being discuss from C2, and now we see animate?TS?addon store?sdkv2? things I really dont care, i just missing friends, pro dev, creative stuff and awesome addon everywhere before now gone you know?

    I think i will stop myself on this thread because i am so tired

  • do you see there is dll file from c3 when you make in windows export? so i am not sure what you're talking about safety? the point is they just let things become more complex, with the same "safety" you told...

    sounds like you're just one of die hard fans who give power to push c3 to be more unreasonable, the c3 win export have nothing "safety" more than old one nwjs if you talking about file control, but just need more line of code to do the same thing, we never discussing the web export i have no problem on it, not sure what are doing if you do try to help, i see you're just explaining for scirra, half of native function(which not cause security issue like resize windows lol) + same safety but more much complex steps to do the same things

    My friend, I don’t want argue with you or anyone, just..... do you really think this is an improvement? I am ok with file system addon in web export but not windows do you get me? You’re not helping C3 with so positive energy to them but not fight for the user right, this windows export is crap compared to NWJS, maybe NWJS will get better security for its common + open source, easy to monitor and not just work with file by a unknown closed source dll which also capableless, you’re pushing who to hell with blind supporting, if you love it, you wont

  • Did you export or just test in preview? The predefined folder tags only work in export. As for why it's more complex, the simple answer would be for security.

    > Browsers impose security restrictions to ensure that general web browsing is safe. Therefore they start with no access to local files or folders at all. The only way to gain access to local files and folders in a browser is to show a picker - a "save file" dialog, an "open file" dialog, or a "pick folder" dialog.

    >

    > Desktop exporters like Windows WebView2 are an exception to this rule and can have direct access to certain special folders like the user's documents folder without any dialogs or permission prompts

    > In Windows WebView2, macOS WKWebView and Linux CEF exports, the browser permission model can be bypassed to directly access folders such as the user's documents folder. This is done by using pre-defined folder picker tags like "<documents>". These act like the folder was already picked on startup. You can check if these are available on startup by using the Has picker tag condition.

    Man, i have completed very projects and large plugins, and I also registered as a forum member around the same time as you... and NWJS have to export it first also?

    10 line of code to work and just 1 line WHY would it be more secure? If I bundle those ten lines of code into one function, would it become less secure? I don't understand your logic.

  • This does the same thing. What limitation are you having trouble with?

    i copy your code and that's not working, even if this code works, it turns what was originally a simple line of code into a huge amount of code. I don't understand why events in 2026 will become more and more complex every day, doing the same thing, but with fewer features (such as resizing the window/retitle).

  • What's your question? How to use local files without nwjs? Use the file system plugin.

    Or are you asking how to export a windows executable?

    like work in native a line of code to read file, not the limited file system plugin

  • (I tried to ensure my word choice and tone didn't violate Scirra's censorship bias, so I repeatedly put my speech into Google Translate to make the article look more friendly.)

    I'm going crazy. This company keeps removing its features even as its user base dwindles. The only correct update over the years is single-file the playable ads one. Other features, like SDK V2 and now the potentially huge NWJS, have been removed instead of being enhanced. Many of my projects that depend on it are now like garbage. Unlike addons I can upgrade from C2 to C3V1 and then to V2 myself, but remove NWJS in this closed-source terrible doesn't allow i change my export selection. Or I supposed to develop a Node.js environment for C3 myself? This is insane. I believe this is like the Qing Dynasty or ancient Indian royalty: Scirra comes up with some cool ideas, and then a few followers reinforce their determination to make the wrong decisions. I don't care anymore; let's see how far they go in one of many wrong direction. Maybe being acquired is a good outcome. Anyway, how am I supposed to manipulate local files as easily as before? Now I can only run two C3 projects: one for the actual work of the new version, and one for manually pasting event sheets into .net/r449-3/ LAST VER OF REAL C3. I don't know how much longer I can continue like this, it's not cool at all, C3 has a bunch of inexplicable limitations. It knows how to unreasonably prevent various behaviors, but it won't clearly tell you when something goes wrong. Anyway, I don't care anymore. Is it really as convenient as NWJS now? That poor webview for Windows is truly poor. What's the point of this kind of webview in 2026? Is it just for 8 years old students to use, is it just a decorative item to make C3 look cool because it supports many platforms, but it has no native functionality? I'm really disappointed. After so many years with C2 then C3, I'm questioning whether I should be like the blindly loyal minority, unconditionally supporting Scirra, even if they push themselves to an extremely wrong position. Should I still praise them? No I Can't! In the Web3 era, since everyone agrees that Sprites object are extremely inconvenient, why not just release a Web3 standard "Image"? At least I could just paste data or a URL to just display an image, instead of going through many complicated steps to play with Sprites. One line of HTML + JS code in C3 becomes many lines. And today I want to use NWJS... Is Scirra now forcing me to develop even NWJS myself? I've already developed many unnecessary plugins, such as multi-multiplayer. They could do it in minutes, but they refuse(Not just me, search the forum will see at lease 3 guys making the same addon, Now i am the only one guy who finish this horrible job, at last).

    They're making things increasingly complicated, deviating further from a simple, direct, and user-friendly approach, and moving towards even more extreme closed-source development. I suspect C3V3/C4 might even block upload addons altogether. Their current Store development direction strongly suggests they'll directly connect C3/4 to their Store, depriving you of your last bit of freedom, right?(They are proud and dislike "overly free" communities, so a central add-on store aligns well with their current direction, Otherwise, the forum removed a place to publish addons, now half-forcing you to pay developer fee to their store. It's laughable, why? cuz Scirra has forgotten the success of C2 and is resting on its laurels, They think success is achieved through their own efforts. That's why they will to block or delete any posts? Happy to "remove" loyal people away, leaving only those who blindly support them. Eventually, the community becomes quieter and quieter, with fewer and fewer people. Enthusiastic people leave year after year.

    Okay, How am I supposed to use C3 like I used to with NWJS? I can't possibly read every single Scirra post in 2026 like I did ten years ago (besides, they don't seem to be doing anything serious these days; it's more like they're pursuing diversification, deleting good stuff and adding what they think is good, wasting a lot of time like still the best: Animation lol, I'm sure Scirra will suddenly release some great ideas soon this year that waste a lot of effort but are ultimately unpopular).

    How can i use new C3 like NWJS C3? or i should remove myself from construct.net

    Tagged:

  • not sure why C3 stop supporting SDKV1

    it's better support C2 stuff also

    anyway the SDK v2 version of CB Hash is here

    https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/cabl38ab8k5mzhnagdzon/CB-Hash-1.c3addon?rlkey=5uulbwvf06579nklrtsy3ehed&st=9qumxr7u&dl=0

    let me know if theres any bug(havent test it yet)

    Kyatric Published on 3 Aug, 2011. Last updated 19 Feb, 2019

    CornedBeef Hash

    CB Hash is a plugin for Construct 2 allowing the user to hash a string and some other parameters, depending on the function, using MD5, javascript implementations of SHA-1 or SHA-256 algorithm.

    * What do the algorithms do ?

    Basicly it takes a string that you'll give it as parameter and after a bit of computation will return it under an hashed form.

    Ex: "Salut à vous" (hello you) returns "807a56a1e5736f1b9fe533dfcb06ebfd"

    The serie of numbers and letters is a hash. A MD5 hash in hexadecimal output.

    Depending on the algorithm and the function, the returned hash will be different in length, use of characters

    - It can be used to compare large amounts of data. You create the hashes for the data, store the hashes and later if you want to compare the data, you just compare the hashes. (known as MD5 checksum)

    - Hashes can be used to index data. They can be used in hash tables to point to the correct row. If you want to quickly find a record, you calculate the hash of the data and directly go to the record where the corresponding hash record is pointing to. (This assumes that you have a sorted list of hashes that point to the actual records)

    - They can be used in cryptographic applications like digital signatures. (That was my main purpose when developping the plugin)

  • All of this can be done without external plugins. Although it's not very convenient.

    If loading external resources becomes more convenient, I will be very happy.

    Please provide the name or link to your plugin. I want to see what features it has.

    dont say that, this is your problem, you're not smart enough like them

    i useto try to let my friends and AI to understand the logic of C3, i failed)