I'm just curious about what you use to make icons.
Develop games in your browser. Powerful, performant & highly capable.
Just use every Graphit program you want.
I take photoshop and then just save it down to 32x32 128x128 or whatever!
I use Paint.NET to draw and GraphicsGale to convert to .ico
If you need .ico files I would like to recommend Greenfish Icon Editor Pro.